Australian cricket icon Greg Chappell has raised significant concerns regarding the national selectors’ choices for the first Ashes Test, particularly the planned opening partnership. With Sam Konstas not in the squad, Marnus Labuschagne is the likely candidate to face the new ball alongside Usman Khawaja, a move Chappell describes as a potentially dangerous overestimation of security.
In his commentary for ESPNcricinfo, Chappell detailed his apprehension. He believes the selectors’ intention is to deploy Labuschagne at the top of the order to facilitate the inclusion of Cameron Green and Beau Webster in the middle order, especially considering Cameron Green’s recent back surgery and limited bowling readiness. “This will allow Cameron Green and Beau Webster to play, giving the best balance of batting and bowling in the squad,” Chappell elaborated, quoting from his analysis.
However, Chappell argued that Labuschagne’s true batting strength lies at number three, where he has consistently performed. “Opening with Labuschagne is extremely risky. He should bat at three, as that is his specialist spot, where he has delivered prolifically,” he asserted. He interprets the consideration of Labuschagne as an opener as a sign of unreliability in other specialist opening options and a concern about the bowling capabilities of Green and Webster.
Referencing the successful careers of Ian Chappell and Ricky Ponting, both renowned No. 3 batsmen, Greg Chappell emphasized that transitioning to an opening role requires a different temperament. He suggested that while both legends often batted early, the specific mindset needed to open an innings is distinct and not universally transferable.
Furthermore, Chappell commented on Labuschagne’s improved batting form this summer, attributing it to a return to an aggressive approach. He warned that an overly conservative batting strategy, while appearing safe, can actually increase the likelihood of getting out. “In this state of mind, the feet do not move, and the runs dry up,” Chappell observed, cautioning that placing Labuschagne out of position could hinder his recent resurgence.